FULL DISCLOSURE: I am not a doctor, or a nutritionist. I am not good in science and I absolutely suck at math. Therefore, please take this post with a grain of salt, or better yet, skip the extra salt completely and just keep reading.
Conventional wisdom states that 3500 calories make a pound. A pound is a pound, whether it is fat, muscle, butter or carrots. It is presumed, that if you reduce your calorie intake by 3500 calories over a period of time, you will lose 1 pound. If you over-consume by that much, you will gain. Makes sense,right? Well, not so fast…
What you eat, and how you burn it off is as important as the elimination of those 3500 calories. Case in point:
I am admittedly obsessive about food and fitness, hence the premise of this blog. I keep a food and activity journal, and try to be as accurate as possible. Based on my current size, if I only consume 1,110 calories per day, I will lost 1 pound per week. Before you all go crazy and think I starve myself, when I enter activity, it adds those calories burned back to my daily food quota. Because I am so active, I am able to eat more than that and still be on target to lose a pound per week.
I take hardcore cycling classes four times per week, I weight train, do weight circuits and toss in a Pilates class when I can for good measure. I also walk 1-1/2 hours per day on average, as transportation. In most people’s eyes, that should be a free pass for the all-you-can-eat fish fry, with extra dessert, right? WRONG!
According to my Lose It app, I have saved 5369 calories over the last 4 weeks, over and above the 3500 per week deficit built in. That would mean I lost 5.5 pounds. According to the scale in my bathroom, I have gained almost that much. Say WHAT?
The big differential for me these last few weeks is not the amount of food I am eating, but the type of food I am eating. Based on my personal experience, here are the cold, hard realities of healthy eating and exercise, according to me:
Just because it came from Whole Foods, or is organic, low fat, gluten free or whatever else the package says, doesn’t mean it’s healthy. Sorry, but real healthy food does not come in a package, and therefore does not state it’s virtures.
I do not have a gluten allergy or celiac disease, and gluten does not make me sick. Foods that contain it however (with the exception of french fries, that would be all the really delicous ones!) make me fat. And by fat, I mean bloated, and thick around the middle. Maybe it’s not the case for you, but for me, if I want a flat belly, I need to lay off the white stuff, most of the time. And while we’re at it, the whole grain goodness of whole wheat isn’t any better on my middle.
For many, many years, I avidly avoided sugar. Not even a bite of a cookie, or a lick of ice-cream. Now, if I have a little sweet something, it makes me want more. Like a junkie, that bite becomes the whole thing. And then I have a stomach ache. My body is trying to tell me something. Why don’t I listen to it? Do you listen to yours? You really should.
Protein is the building block of muscle or something like that. (See disclosure above.) I am clearly not eating enough of it lately. I don’t like meat, so getting to the fish market has to be a priority, otherwise I just eat fruit and vegetables, and later become ravenous and down half a bag of trail mix or something else masquerading as “healthy” in a package in my pantry. It’s important to fuel properly during the day to avoid the ravenous binge, especially post workout.
My exercise routine is intense, followed by long stretches of sitting on my butt in front of a computer or drawing table all day. I get out of my chair sometimes and can barely move I’m so stiff. Studies show that even a couple of hours a day of physical activity cannot offset being sedentary for the rest of the day. I need to get up and move around every few hours, to rev my metabolism and stretch my sore limbs. Perhaps a stroll to the nearest fish market would solve multiple issues?
While we are on the subject of walking, I regret to inform you that walking does not burn very many calories. For those of you that think walking for 30 minutes per day a few times a week is exercising, you are wrong. It is better than not moving at all, but it doesn’t do much for increasing your heart rate or decreasing your fat rate. Lose It says that I burned 69 calories during a 30 minute walk, or the equivalent of 1-1/2 tablespoons of trail mix. And that’s not the kind with M&M’s in it. Bummer, right?
This is the calorie equivalent of a 30 minute brisk walk.
The media touts salt as an enemy. It’s not the salt that we sprinkle on our home cooked meals that is the problem. It’s the huge amounts lurking in those bags and tetra packs, and glass jars (no plastic please! ) that is the issue. That organic, gluten free, low fat, high fiber soup my be a BPA free sodium bomb. Making soup is so easy and tastes so much better. It’s time to get off my duff and make a few different kinds to put in the freezer in individual containers so that I can have homemade convenience foods at the ready. While salt doesn’t cause fat gain, that jump in the scale after consuming large quantities of it is due to good old bloat. Drinking a lot of water can help to eliminate the retained water in a day or two.
The bottom line is that whole foods; the kind that are produced by nature, not factories, are the best for us. There is no debate there. Eating the freshest, highest quality foods, without added chemicals, additives and flavorings will produce the best results in terms of health, fuel and weight management.
Moving throughout the day is important for your health, but adding bouts of high intensity activity ( intervals for example,) will yield you better results.
It’s true what they say: You can’t out train a bad diet, and abs really are made in the kitchen, not in the gym.
Tags: belly fat, bloat, carbs, diet, fat, fitness, fresh food, health, nutrition, packaged foods, protein, sugar, trail mix, unhealthy health foods
Indigo jones 
September 29, 2014 at 8:30 am |
UGH. I know this because I see the same thing for myself but I’ve never seen it laid out with so many cold, hard, scary facts.Thank you I think… The one thing you did not include though that makes it even worse is age….that’s the real bummer. As in, for many years, my 5X per week Bikram Yoga class was enough for me to do to be able to eat (and drink) pretty much whatever I wanted and maintain my weight. The one caveat there is that naughty white stuff–I’ve always tried to stay clear of that. Now to move the needle on the scale it takes such a Herculean effort….so depressing. Better get off my BUTT and go do something:) PS As someone who knows you in the real world Indigo Jones, I think your readers would love to see a photo of you to understand how truly successful you are at living a healthy lifestyle:)
September 29, 2014 at 10:52 am |
Thanks for commenting! Yes, age is a factor, although I try not to use it as an excuse. When I was 25 all I wanted to do was gain weight.
October 9, 2014 at 6:51 am |
[…] week I wrote about the flawed concept of “calories in/calories out,” based on my own, non-expert findings. Today, a real expert weighs in on weight fluctuation, and […]